|
Post by Bioshock Infinite WD on Dec 13, 2014 23:02:34 GMT
Oh dear... that's like cheering when Duck died... WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU!!! They actually did cheer when Duck died. For the record, I replaced Long Road Ahead today.... still got teary eyed at Duck and Katjaa's deaths. Oh.... don't remember that, well, that sheds a light on the situation, and who doesn't? I think episode 3 was the major turning point, where everyone realized this was not just a good game, sure was for me.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2014 5:59:51 GMT
Oh dear... that's like cheering when Duck died... WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU!!! They actually did cheer when Duck died. For the record, I replaced Long Road Ahead today.... still got teary eyed at Duck and Katjaa's deaths. Season 2 is so much more emotional, right? Where we get lazy, lame deaths in place of well written, truly emotional scenes.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2014 11:32:38 GMT
They actually did cheer when Duck died. For the record, I replaced Long Road Ahead today.... still got teary eyed at Duck and Katjaa's deaths. Season 2 is so much more emotional, right? Where we get lazy, lame deaths in place of well written, truly emotional scenes. I liked Alvin's death scene in Episode 3, that was actually pretty well done, and if I were more on the fence about Kenny, on the fence enough to have shot him, I'm sure that would have reduced me to tears. I'll be honest, replaying the ending, it actually wasn't done very well, the final scene. Everything is still there so I'm sure if I'd been playing i for the first time, I would have cried or at the very least been depressed, but now looking back on it, it could have been done better, especially when I played Episode 3 the day before and I realize that Duck and Katjaa deaths were done better(as far as how the scene played out. At the time, having to direct Clem whilst Lee was on the floor was very emotional, and still would work, but then I get the feeling that Clem is an idiot since Lee has to direct her to do everything in that scene, especially when I accidentally clicked "look at" and Lee ended up basically saying the same thing twice, the difference was, one time, she did it, the other time, she didn't).
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:08:40 GMT
Season 2 is so much more emotional, right? Where we get lazy, lame deaths in place of well written, truly emotional scenes. I liked Alvin's death scene in Episode 3, that was actually pretty well done, and if I were more on the fence about Kenny, on the fence enough to have shot him, I'm sure that would have reduced me to tears. I'll be honest, replaying the ending, it actually wasn't done very well, the final scene. Everything is still there so I'm sure if I'd been playing i for the first time, I would have cried or at the very least been depressed, but now looking back on it, it could have been done better, especially when I played Episode 3 the day before and I realize that Duck and Katjaa deaths were done better(as far as how the scene played out. At the time, having to direct Clem whilst Lee was on the floor was very emotional, and still would work, but then I get the feeling that Clem is an idiot since Lee has to direct her to do everything in that scene, especially when I accidentally clicked "look at" and Lee ended up basically saying the same thing twice, the difference was, one time, she did it, the other time, she didn't). Alvin's episode 3 death, and Pete's episode 2 death are the exception. But Katjaa and Duck still get to me. They still pry my heart right open, because the game made me relate with those fake people, and care about their well being. The ending was pretty bad. I'd say the only side with any real effort put into it was siding with Kenny. Jane seemed to just be a psycho fucking bitch, and the only emotional payoff was calling her fucking crazy, and leaving her, with the one person left that mattered.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:15:07 GMT
I liked Alvin's death scene in Episode 3, that was actually pretty well done, and if I were more on the fence about Kenny, on the fence enough to have shot him, I'm sure that would have reduced me to tears. I'll be honest, replaying the ending, it actually wasn't done very well, the final scene. Everything is still there so I'm sure if I'd been playing i for the first time, I would have cried or at the very least been depressed, but now looking back on it, it could have been done better, especially when I played Episode 3 the day before and I realize that Duck and Katjaa deaths were done better(as far as how the scene played out. At the time, having to direct Clem whilst Lee was on the floor was very emotional, and still would work, but then I get the feeling that Clem is an idiot since Lee has to direct her to do everything in that scene, especially when I accidentally clicked "look at" and Lee ended up basically saying the same thing twice, the difference was, one time, she did it, the other time, she didn't). Alvin's episode 3 death, and Pete's episode 2 death are the exception. But Katjaa and Duck still get to me. They still pry my heart right open, because the game made me relate with those fake people, and care about their well being. The ending was pretty bad. I'd say the only side with any real effort put into it was siding with Kenny. Jane seemed to just be a psycho fucking bitch, and the only emotional payoff was calling her fucking crazy, and leaving her, with the one person left that mattered. (I meant the S1 Ending) And yeah, Pete's death in E2.... That also got to me. I'l admit, there's a lot wrong with Season Two, Season One was definitely better, but I still hold that S2 was a worthy sequel, and if they manage to do handle the S2 endings right, then S3 has some real potential.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:20:07 GMT
Alvin's episode 3 death, and Pete's episode 2 death are the exception. But Katjaa and Duck still get to me. They still pry my heart right open, because the game made me relate with those fake people, and care about their well being. The ending was pretty bad. I'd say the only side with any real effort put into it was siding with Kenny. Jane seemed to just be a psycho fucking bitch, and the only emotional payoff was calling her fucking crazy, and leaving her, with the one person left that mattered. (I meant the S1 Ending) And yeah, Pete's death in E2.... That also got to me. I'l admit, there's a lot wrong with Season Two, Season One was definitely better, but I still hold that S2 was a worthy sequel, and if they manage to do handle the S2 endings right, then S3 has some real potential. Wow, you meant the season 1 ending? Damn, heartless. Granted, it's not as sad as it once was, but all sadness fades over time. And that's a very petty complaint to make. "Man, the look at and the command were similar. Grr, bad ending!" I'm just sad that I didn't get the Pete death in episode 2, but I sure am glad that I got more time with Nick, in a way that was still very sad... I guess. Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is.
|
|
|
Post by Rock114 on Dec 16, 2014 1:23:49 GMT
(I meant the S1 Ending) And yeah, Pete's death in E2.... That also got to me. I'l admit, there's a lot wrong with Season Two, Season One was definitely better, but I still hold that S2 was a worthy sequel, and if they manage to do handle the S2 endings right, then S3 has some real potential. Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is. ...but the first time he played it, he DID consider it a worthy sequel. In fact, he considered it better than Season 1 after his playthrough.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:28:03 GMT
Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is. ...but the first time he played it, he DID consider it a worthy sequel. In fact, he considered it better than Season 1 after his playthrough. But it was a long time after playing Season 1. Now that he realizes Season 1's greatness, he should compare it to Season 2 in a more objective, and informed light.
|
|
|
Post by Bioshock Infinite WD on Dec 16, 2014 1:33:01 GMT
(I meant the S1 Ending) And yeah, Pete's death in E2.... That also got to me. I'l admit, there's a lot wrong with Season Two, Season One was definitely better, but I still hold that S2 was a worthy sequel, and if they manage to do handle the S2 endings right, then S3 has some real potential. Wow, you meant the season 1 ending? Damn, heartless. Granted, it's not as sad as it once was, but all sadness fades over time. And that's a very petty complaint to make. "Man, the look at and the command were similar. Grr, bad ending!" I'm just sad that I didn't get the Pete death in episode 2, but I sure am glad that I got more time with Nick, in a way that was still very sad... I guess. Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is. Season 1 ending not good what? I liked season 2, but come on, season 1 ending not being good? Good god man, it still tears at the heart to this day.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:33:59 GMT
Wow, you meant the season 1 ending? Damn, heartless. Granted, it's not as sad as it once was, but all sadness fades over time. And that's a very petty complaint to make. "Man, the look at and the command were similar. Grr, bad ending!" I'm just sad that I didn't get the Pete death in episode 2, but I sure am glad that I got more time with Nick, in a way that was still very sad... I guess. Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is. Season 1 ending not good what? I liked season 2, but come on, season 1 ending not being good? Good god man, it still tears at the heart to this day. Why are you replying to me?
|
|
|
Post by Bioshock Infinite WD on Dec 16, 2014 1:34:30 GMT
Season 1 ending not good what? I liked season 2, but come on, season 1 ending not being good? Good god man, it still tears at the heart to this day. Why are you replying to me? Oh shit, sorry, I didn't look, sorry.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:45:42 GMT
Wow, you meant the season 1 ending? Damn, heartless. Granted, it's not as sad as it once was, but all sadness fades over time. And that's a very petty complaint to make. "Man, the look at and the command were similar. Grr, bad ending!" I'm just sad that I didn't get the Pete death in episode 2, but I sure am glad that I got more time with Nick, in a way that was still very sad... I guess. Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is. Season 1 ending not good what? I liked season 2, but come on, season 1 ending not being good? Good god man, it still tears at the heart to this day. I never, ever, said that, or did not mean to convey that. What I meant was I felt like some scenes, had better dialogue, or were smoother, or, etc, etc. I still think it's fantastic.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:48:18 GMT
Season 1 ending not good what? I liked season 2, but come on, season 1 ending not being good? Good god man, it still tears at the heart to this day. I never, ever, said that, or did not mean to convey that. What I meant was I felt like some scenes, had better dialogue, or were smoother, or, etc, etc. I still think it's fantastic. "I'll be honest, replaying the ending, it actually wasn't done very well, the final scene."
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:51:21 GMT
(I meant the S1 Ending) And yeah, Pete's death in E2.... That also got to me. I'l admit, there's a lot wrong with Season Two, Season One was definitely better, but I still hold that S2 was a worthy sequel, and if they manage to do handle the S2 endings right, then S3 has some real potential. Wow, you meant the season 1 ending? Damn, heartless. Granted, it's not as sad as it once was, but all sadness fades over time. And that's a very petty complaint to make. "Man, the look at and the command were similar. Grr, bad ending!" I'm just sad that I didn't get the Pete death in episode 2, but I sure am glad that I got more time with Nick, in a way that was still very sad... I guess. Season 2 is a very unworthy sequel. Replay it again, but without the mindset of someone who's played it a bunch. Play it thinking like someone playing it the first time, and you will realize just how poor it is. I didn't mean that the sadness fades over time, more what I meant was that since I'm not playing it for the first time, I'm now noticing stuff that kind of draws me out of it, there are some lines from Melissa Hutchinson that are a bit off, just stuff like that, whereas other scenes(Duck and Katjaa's death, Wellington/Kenny ending, Pete's death, etc.) are just more smooth, tighter, more well put together. I don't think it's worse than the other scenes, it's just something I noticed. It's still fucking great though. I am going to replay it again within the next few days. Well, probably. I just got Elegy for a Dead World, and that's right up my alley, so I may spend some time doing that, but the whole reason for why I played Season One, was because I wanted to go through both Seasons trying to look at it with new eyes, and reevaluate my opinion. It's possible my opinion will change, but right now, my biggest problem with it looking back on a lot of the scenes, the wasted potential is obvious in almost every episode(aside from A House Divided, but even then, that would have been better if they hadn't put the "I thought you were dead" line in the preview. Glad Telltale learned from that experience though, removing a certain line from the GoT preview for E2).
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 16, 2014 1:52:07 GMT
I never, ever, said that, or did not mean to convey that. What I meant was I felt like some scenes, had better dialogue, or were smoother, or, etc, etc. I still think it's fantastic. "I'll be honest, replaying the ending, it actually wasn't done very well, the final scene." It can be a little poorly put together, but still be good, which was my meaning. I didn't mean to convey that I thought it was bad.
|
|