Episode 4 choice thread

I saved Sarah. I wasn't going to just leave her there. And her death if you leave her is just heartbreaking.

I went with Mike and Bonnie first because Mike.

I did not rob Arvo. I was actually counting on him and his group coming in to save us during the attack like the cavalry because I had been so nice to him and let him keep his medicine. Needless to say, fuck Arvo.

I didn't go through the gap. As a naturally lazy individual, I saw the opportunity to make someone else do something for once and I took it. Also, I knew it was good odds that a zombie was in there.

I held the baby, because why not?

I accepted the nail file because free shit is the best shit.

I decided to leave in the morning. It was starting to snow, and I figured that we needed better shelter for Rebecca and the baby.

Shot Rebecca. As soon as the intimidating Russian guys with guns emerged from the woods, I knew there was no way to avoid a shootout so I wasn't very concerned about being the one to start it. Plus it was for a good cause. I saved a baby.

I told Jane to go down and save Sarah. I felt kind of like an asshole for making Jane risk her life like that, but I wasn't ready to accept that Sarah was going to die there.

- Saved Sarah. Most of you probably know my feelings on her by now so I won't beat a dead horse anymore. I refused to give up on her.

- Went with Jane first. I didn't think she'd take off, but I didn't fully trust her.

- Robbed Arvo. This was a very difficult decision for me, because stealing medicine from a disabled kid with a (possibly) sick sister is like the most douchebag move I could think of. But ultimately, I really did need the medicine what with Kenny's eye, Rebecca going into labor, and Luke's ribs. Though I couldn't understand why we couldn't just take a couple of bottles and let him have the rest.

And then Arvo turned out to be a colossal dick and I stopped caring.

- Went through the gap. Actually didn't know I had a choice in the matter, I figured they'd just push me into it if I said no.

- Held the baby because I like Rebecca and I'm not an asshole.

- Accepted the nail file. Why not.

- Waited a day to leave. I was worried about Rebecca, though I regretted it when I saw she had gotten worse. Also kind of wanted to go back and side with Kenny out of spite when Luke turned all passive-aggressive on me for telling the two of them to stop fighting.

- Called out for help, because I could see that twist of them panicking at the sound of a gunshot a mile away. But Kenny fucked it up anyway. ://////

Told Jane to save Sarah. I knew the second she fell it was the end for her, though I was surprised it killed her off in this episode no matter what, but I wasn't going to let her blood be on my hands.

You know what is BANANAS? According to the stats at the end of the episode, the majority, 53%, left Sarah at the trailer park. Never, ever would have guessed that.

Mine:

- Saved Sarah. Stupid fuckin' pinky swear.
- Went with Jane first. I didn't want to. I thought I had spent enough time with her already. But I didn't trust her.
- Stole from Arvo. I realize that this goes against EVERYTHING that season 1 Clem stood for. I was thinking that someone from the group would die if I didn't steal the meds though. Sue me.
- Went through the gap. Yeah, I kinda figured a walker would be on the other end. I just wanted to see what would happen.
- Held baby. Not eagerly though. Whoever didn't choose "I don't know how" is a sucker.
- Accepted the nail file. ... Why wouldn't I?
- Left a day later. It was obvious enough that the group could have used some rest.
- Shot Rebecca. Had to be put down ASAP.
- Told Jane to save Sarah. Again... stupid fuckin' pinky swear.

Saved Sarah

Went with Jane first, but I didn't know that was a choice. If I did, I would've gone with Mike and Bonnie for sure.

Didn't rob Arvo. He didn't, and doesn't deserve it.

I said I didn't really want to, but I didn't realize that Bonnie would almost get bit because of it. If I did, I would've gone in without a second thought.

Held the baby, because fuck yeah, a baby.

Refused the file. I don't want anything to connect me to Jane, because fuck her.

Shot Rebecca, because it was quicker.

Told Jane to save Sarah. I wish I could've dropped her myself. If she didn't waste so much fucking time, then she would've saved Sarah.

Yeah that choice was hard with Arvo, good job Telltale on that, well I saved Sarah because we were good friends, we pinky swore, and its forever  I went with Mike and Bonnie because I cared more about them and thought maybe they would not be safe, I went through the gap, Clem had done this many times in the past, held the baby, because why not?  It's a baby, I refused the nail file because I thought she needed it more then I did, I left a day later, I was wrong we should have left in the morning, I called for help, because I knew what would happen if I shot, so I called for help hoping... I don't know what I was hoping for, and I told Jane to save Sarah, it was a hard choice, but I did that because I really cared about her, almost like a sister.

I can basically get behind that stament. Although I will be keeping the knee trick.

First Playthrough

Saved Sarah

Went with Jane first

Stole from Arvo

Went through the gap

Held baby

Accepted nail file

Left a day later

Called for help

Told Jane to save Sarah


Second Playthrough

Did everything the same except I let Bonnie reach through the gap.